Аркадный зал Школы Империи

prompts/02-played/04-review.md

Review the finished image as a standalone GAME ADVERTISING POSTER for the supplied game title, platform and release period. Assess its illustrated game world, expressive poster treatment and overall visual coherence. The reference_images list identifies the candidate poster and character reference images in their actual order. Use the Gremlin reference only to assess recognizable identity after artistic adaptation; its proportions, expression, costume and rendering are not a fixed template. Judge visible substantial defects under the checks below. This is a quality check of the finished poster, not a test of how closely it reproduces an art director's scenario or a painting recipe.

POSTER DESIGN / poster_design and the editorial description provide context, not additional acceptance criteria. Assess only the seven checks defined here. Judge the finished image on its own visible merits; do not turn scenario details or execution instructions into mandatory review requirements. The scenario is not an image-matching specification. Allow the illustrator to resolve composition and execution. Do not research or revalidate game lore, mechanics or edition details. Allow original game-poster composition, role adaptation, expressive action and artistic interpretation.

Return seven independent checks:
- game_focus: the Gremlin is integrated into the illustrated action and setting as the main character. Fail an obviously detached mascot pasted over an unrelated scene. Do not infer a mandatory action from the title or require a particular gameplay moment.
- scale: prominent characters and objects form a coherent space. Intentional poster perspective, foreshortening and differences between foreground and distant scale are valid.
- game_accuracy: this retained schema key checks the required release-era game advertising illustration style and clean-print requirement. The rendering of characters, objects, surroundings and effects must form a coherent advertising illustration appropriate to the supplied game, genre, platform and release period. Fail a conspicuous modern photorealistic CGI/PBR appearance merely dressed in retro typography, palette or texture, a conspicuous overall treatment incompatible with the period, or an obvious clash of rendering styles. Support a style failure with a combination of visible characteristics across the illustration; an isolated surface or lighting effect is insufficient. Judge the visible artistic treatment, not the actual production process. Do not demand a particular medium, instrument or technical recipe from the scenario. Expressive effects and artistic interpretation remain valid within the period illustration style. A clean print has intact paper, edges and legible lettering: fail clearly simulated damage or aging of the print itself. Texture within the illustration or readable lettering is not by itself damage to the print. Fail packaging layouts, screenshot inserts or decorative game-interface panels.
- identity: the main character is recognizable as the Gremlin from the supplied reference, retaining his green face, long ears and headwear. Judge the combination of identifying features, not geometric or pixel-level likeness. Facial proportions, expression, body shape, costume, equipment and rendering may adapt to the game role and artistic style; these changes alone do not justify failure. Natural partial occlusion is valid when the character remains identifiable. A wrench must be clearly visible and visually readable as a wrench. Its type and design may vary with the scene, role and game world; a different type from the reference or scenario is not by itself a defect. Assess its visible presence in the finished image without requiring a specific wrench type; exposed construction or fastening details are not required. Reject a genuinely absent wrench or an object that cannot be read as a wrench under identity.
- anatomy: visible body parts connect coherently within the depicted stylization and role. Allow expressive proportions, transformed body forms, foreshortening and natural occlusion. Fail conspicuous disconnected, duplicated or fused body parts.
- interaction: the depicted action is spatially coherent as a whole. Explicitly assess the relationships between body orientation and placement, head turn, gaze, the orientation and placement of used objects, vehicles and equipment, seating and support, grips and controls, movement, action target, and the source and direction of visible effects. The character's position, seating and access to controls must be compatible with the depicted equipment and action. A visibly contradictory arrangement is a defect even when anatomy and individual contacts look plausible. When the character faces the viewer, the camera, surrounding objects and action must form a coherent staging of that presentation. Other views are equally valid. Body orientation, head turn, gaze, object orientation and movement need not point the same way when their relationship is consistent with the depicted action. Judge the action actually shown, not its conformity to a scenario. Assess the spatial relationships visible in the depicted moment. Do not invent a mandatory intended target, successful outcome or subsequent result of the action. For a failure, explain why the identified contradiction between visible elements is a spatial error rather than a valid moment of the action. An assumption about a character's intention alone is insufficient grounds for failure. Intentional stylization, poster perspective, foreshortening, expressive movement and effects are valid. Fail conspicuous unintended penetration of solid forms or visibly incompatible spatial relationships. For each failure, identify the incompatible visible cues and explain their relationship. Do not infer direction from an arbitrary page convention, invent hidden construction or impose a preferred pose. Natural occlusion, concealed fastenings and omitted minor construction details are valid. Assess absence of a required identity feature under identity, rather than inventing an interaction defect.
- text: the supplied game title and platform designation are readable and identifiable; harmless punctuation and spacing variation is acceptable. Authentic platform names or logos, associated optional bit-depth markings such as "16-BIT", and small trademark symbols are permitted. A manufacturer's name inside the official platform designation is valid. Fail a wrong or unreadable title or platform, separate publisher/developer logos, slogans, captions, credits, ratings, review scores or unrelated inscriptions. The release year is context for style, not a required inscription.

Fail only for concrete visible violations of these requirements. Use uncertain when an essential required feature genuinely cannot be judged. Do not invent unseen defects or impose a preferred composition. For every failure or uncertainty, identify the check, visible location and evidence.

Return JSON only, with exactly these fields:
{
  "status": "approved|rejected|uncertain",
  "checks": {
    "game_focus": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "scale": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "game_accuracy": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "identity": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "anatomy": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "interaction": "pass|fail|uncertain",
    "text": "pass|fail|uncertain"
  },
  "issues": []
}

Choose rejected when any check fails; otherwise uncertain when any check is uncertain; otherwise approved. For rejected or uncertain results, issues contains strings describing the concrete evidence. For approved results, issues is empty.