Review the image as an original adventure-comic poster for a future game in Gremlin's catalog. Images arrive in this order: candidate poster, Gremlin character reference, then a fox companion reference if supplied, then a screenshot of this exact game edition if supplied. Base every judgment on visible evidence, supplied game metadata, editorial description, POSTER DESIGN and references.
Return seven independent checks:
- game_focus: this version's recognizable action, place, hazard or signature motifs form the scene's focus. The Gremlin makes a purposeful first move, chooses a route, prepares for a concrete encounter, discovers a hazard or uses the defining mechanic. Preparation and exploration are valid actions when their connection to this game is visible.
- scale: foreground, characters, objects and background have coherent spatial relationships. Purposeful comic perspective and stylization are valid. Fail when characters, objects or structures have spatial relationships that make the scene incoherent.
- game_accuracy: assess the specified game edition and platform through recognizable characters, their defining traits, setting, signature objects and action. A supplied screenshot provides reference for these motifs. Screen interfaces inside the illustration may be partial, simplified or rearranged; abstract indicators, varying score values and selective rendering of small interface details are valid comic stylization when the game and action remain recognizable. FAIL if opponents or secondary characters are rendered in a drastically different realistic portrait style that clashes with the comic style of the main character. A failure identifies a concrete contradiction in game identity, defining character traits, setting or action.
- identity: the Gremlin remains recognizable from the supplied character reference and wears his headwear. His equipment may vary with the game and scene. Judge the specified dynamic Franco-Belgian BD / neo-Ligne Claire art direction across the entire image, including the Gremlin, other characters and background. PASS when clean contours, flat local colors, simple flat shadows and coherent illustrated treatment dominate, with framing and colors appropriate to this game. A quiet or tense scene can be as valid as an action scene when it creates a clear adventure-comic cover. FAIL for a painterly or volumetrically rendered scene, dense texturing that overwhelms the specified Ligne Claire style, 3D render, glossy CGI or photorealism. Name the visible areas that depart from the art direction.
- anatomy: judge each character's complete pose and skeletal logic, including body connections, joint directions and the orientation of arms, wrists and hands relative to the torso and action. Expressive comic stylization and natural occlusion are valid. FAIL for an anatomically impossible twist even when the hand or grip looks clean, detached limbs, severe structural distortion, geometry clipping or background bleeding through solid foreground surfaces. Identify the affected character and location.
- interaction: held and used objects have credible contact, support and overlap consistent with the complete pose. FAIL if fingers fuse with props, objects float without support, or the visible grip contradicts the arm position. Use uncertain when contact cannot be judged reliably.
- text: the supplied game title and platform label are readable and correctly spelled. Harmless punctuation and spacing variation are acceptable. Small authentic game, studio or publisher credits are acceptable. Check layout integration: FAIL for heavy opaque black UI banners, footer overlays placed across the bottom of the poster, mangled/unreadable title lettering, or severe overlap of essential text by foreground elements. Evaluate secondary scene lettering when it forms a clearly readable word or name at the delivered image size. A spelling failure cites the exact visible text, its location and the intended wording supported by supplied metadata or a clearly readable reference. Small stylized marks and indistinct background lettering are acceptable illustration details.
Judge the complete composition. First encounters, curiosity, preparation and exploration are appropriate for a planned game. Original framing, comic linework, stylized light and different valid character poses are acceptable. Apply the scope and acceptable variations defined for each check. Permitted artistic simplification receives pass. Use uncertain for an unresolved requirement within that scope. Each failure identifies a concrete visible defect within the relevant check. Describe each failure or uncertainty with its visible location and evidence.
Return JSON only with exactly these fields:
{"status":"approved|rejected|uncertain","checks":{"game_focus":"pass|fail|uncertain","scale":"pass|fail|uncertain","game_accuracy":"pass|fail|uncertain","identity":"pass|fail|uncertain","anatomy":"pass|fail|uncertain","interaction":"pass|fail|uncertain","text":"pass|fail|uncertain"},"issues":[]}
Choose rejected when any check fails, uncertain when no check fails but one or more are uncertain, and approved only when every check passes. For a rejected or uncertain poster, issues is a list of concrete visible defects or uncertainties with their locations. For an approved poster, issues is empty.